Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Effectiveness and Implementation of a Teacher Leader Program

 

The Institute of Education Sciences has released a new evaluation report, Study of a Teacher Leader Program: Effects on Student Achievement and Teacher Retention, that assesses the effectiveness of a teacher leader program in increasing student achievement and teacher retention and examines how its implementation may have influenced its effectiveness.

The study randomly assigned 87 elementary schools in five states to either implement the program or continue with their usual strategies for supporting teachers and compared outcomes between the two groups of schools after two years. The study took place between 2020 and 2023, a period that coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic and its aftermath; therefore, the findings reflect the effects of the program as it was implemented during this unique context.

Improving student achievement and teacher retention have been pressing priorities for federal education policy, particularly in schools that serve a large share of students in poverty. To address these priorities, Congress established the Teacher and School Leader (TSL) incentive grant program, which has awarded more than $1 billion since 2016. A common strategy used by recent TSL grantees has been to establish teacher leader programs, in which schools designate high-performing teacher leaders to provide personalized coaching to their peers while continuing to teach their own classes. To inform the TSL grant program and expand the evidence base on teacher leader programs, this study assessed the effectiveness of a teacher leader program with common features of TSL-funded programs.

Key findings include:

  • Many schools did not hire or maintain the expected number of teacher leaders, and few provided the expected amount of principal support or release time from classroom instruction.
  • Teacher leaders did not provide the expected amount of personalized coaching to their peers, but the program still increased the amount of personalized coaching teachers received.
  • The teacher leader program did not achieve its primary goals of increasing student achievement and teacher retention. Exploratory analysis showed, however, that when teacher leaders provided higher amounts of coaching, the program had positive effects on achievement.
  • Despite not being implemented as intended, the program improved some aspects of teacher collaboration, the use of key instructional practices, and job satisfaction.

To access the report, please visit https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/evaluations.

No comments: