Thursday, November 19, 2026

Key psychological risk factor may help explain growing anxiety among young adults


Analysis of more than 35,000 college students found intolerance of uncertainty increased steadily from 1992 to 2023, with the rate of increase tripling after 2012 


Intolerance of uncertainty—a key psychological risk factor for anxiety—increased steadily among college-aged young adults in Canada and the United States between 1992 and 2023, with the sharpest rise beginning around 2012, finds a new study by Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and Boston University School of Public Health. The increase was about three times faster from 2012 to 2023 than during the previous two decades. The study is published in JAMA Psychiatry.

The findings suggest that rising intolerance of uncertainty (IU)—the tendency to struggle with situations in which important information is unknown or outcomes are unpredictable—may be one mechanism underlying the growing prevalence of anxiety and mood disorders among young adults. Although IU is considered one of the central psychological processes involved in anxiety, little research has examined whether changes in IU over time parallel the well-documented increase in anxiety among young adults.

"Our results provide updated insights into one of the core building blocks of anxiety: intolerance of uncertainty," said Katherine M. Keyes, PhD, professor of Epidemiology at Columbia Mailman, and senior author. "IU is not itself a health outcome or a root cause of disease, but an intermediary cognitive process that contributes to the development of anxiety."

For example, someone with high intolerance of uncertainty may feel they need to know exactly what to expect before attending class or a social gathering and become anxious or distressed when they cannot predict what will happen. People with higher IU are at greater risk for multiple anxiety and mood disorders.

Using the database Web of Science – a gold standard platform for citation research-- the authors identified peer-reviewed studies of college students in the U.S. and Canada published between 2007 and 2025. After screening nearly 300 full-text articles, they analyzed data from 138 studies representing 35,296 participants who completed either the 27-item or 12-item Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale.

Across the study period, average IU scores increased by approximately 0.65 points per year from 1992 through 2023. The rate of increase accelerated markedly around 2012, with IU rising about three times faster during 2012-2023 than during 1992-2011.

"The important role of IU in the treatment of anxiety disorders raised our interest in studying trends in IU over time," said Jeroen M. Van Baar, PhD, postdoctoral associate, Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public Health, and first author. "There have been many reports of anxiety and depression symptoms becoming more common among young adults over the past two decades, but we knew little about how intolerance of uncertainty has changed since 2014. If IU plays an important role in anxiety and depression, we would expect it to have increased alongside these conditions."

The researchers say the findings also provide new context for understanding what may be driving today's youth mental health crisis. A number of societal changes—including increased smartphone and social media use, greater academic pressure, loneliness, economic instability, childhood adversity, and the COVID-19 pandemic—may all contribute to rising intolerance of uncertainty.

"It is likely that these factors are intertwined and mutually reinforcing, jointly contributing to population-level increases in intolerance of uncertainty and anxiety among young adults," said Van Baar. "Any explanation will be strongest if it accounts for both the long-term upward trend since the 1990s and the inflection point observed around 2012."

The findings may also help address an ongoing debate over whether rising rates of anxiety simply reflect greater awareness of mental health rather than true increases in underlying psychological distress.

"Some researchers have argued that increases in anxiety and mood disorder symptoms among young people may partly reflect greater mental health awareness," noted Van Baar. "Because young people are now more familiar with terms like 'anxiety’, they may be more likely to report symptoms in surveys even if their underlying feelings have not changed. On the other hand, intolerance of uncertainty remains a relatively unfamiliar concept outside psychology, making this study less vulnerable to that criticism.”

"The fact that we observed a consistent increase in intolerance of uncertainty that mirrored trends in anxiety and mood disorder symptoms suggests these patterns are unlikely to be explained solely by greater mental health awareness and may instead reflect genuine changes in underlying mental health,” said Keyes.

"The persistent increase in intolerance of uncertainty justifies continued research into the role of uncertainty in the epidemiology of anxiety and the development of interventions that effectively reduce IU,” added Keyes. “Our findings suggest that reducing intolerance of uncertainty may help curb the rise of anxiety and mood disorder symptoms among young adults. The encouraging news is that effective interventions to reduce IU already exist for people with anxiety and mood disorders."

JAMA Psychiatry

Creatine supplement use nearly doubles among US college students,

 

 The use of creatine and protein supplements among U.S. college and university students has increased significantly over a five-year period, according to new research led by researchers at the University of Toronto. 

The study, which analyzed data from nearly 40,000 college and university students aged 18 to 30 years across the United States, found that lifetime creatine supplement use increased from 7.7% in the 2020-2021 academic year to 13.5% in 2024-2025. Protein supplement use also increased, from 23.8% to 28.0% over the same period. 

The findings highlight the growing popularity of muscle-building dietary supplements among young adults and underscore the importance of education, screening, and harm-reduction efforts on college and university campuses. 

"Creatine and protein supplements have become increasingly common among young people, particularly those seeking to build muscle, improve their physical appearance, or enhance athletic performance," said Kyle T. Ganson, PhD, MSW, Associate Professor at the University of Toronto's Factor-Inwentash Faculty of Social Work and lead author of the study. "Our findings suggest that these products are becoming a more prominent behavior among college students, making it important for health professionals to understand why young people are using them and how to support safe and informed decision-making." 

Using data from the Healthy Minds Study, a large annual survey of U.S. college and university students, researchers examined trends in the lifetime use of appearance- and performance-enhancing drugs and substances (APEDS) between 2020 and 2025. The study included 39,986 students and assessed the use of protein supplements, creatine supplements, anabolic-androgenic steroids, other synthetic muscle enhancers, and diuretics or water pills. 

Among the key findings: 

  • Creatine supplement use increased substantially: Lifetime use rose from 7.7% in 2020-2021 to 13.5% in 2024-2025, representing a relative increase of approximately 75%. 

  • Protein supplement use also increased: Lifetime use rose from 23.8% to 28.0% over the same period, representing a relative increase of approximately 18%. 

  • Men reported significantly higher use: After accounting for other sociodemographic characteristics, cisgender men were more than fourfold more likely to report creatine supplement use and approximately 1.6 times as likely to report protein supplement use compared to cisgender women. 

  • Student-athletes were more likely to use supplements: Students participating in intramural, club, or varsity athletics reported significantly higher use of both protein and creatine supplements compared to students not involved in athletics. 

  • Anabolic steroid use remained relatively uncommon: Lifetime use of anabolic-androgenic steroids and other synthetic muscle enhancers was below 0.5% across all five survey years. 

Overall, nearly three-quarters of participants (73.2%) reported never using any of the substances assessed, while approximately one in four reported using at least one. 

“The increasing use of muscle-building supplements may reflect broader cultural pressures surrounding muscularity, fitness, and physical appearance, particularly among boys and young men,” says Ganson. “Our prior research has shown that viewing content on social media related to fitness or muscle-building is associated with the use of supplements like creatine and pre-workout.” 

Social media platforms have become prominent sources of fitness and nutrition information, exposing young people to content promoting muscular bodies, intensive exercise routines, and supplement use.  

"We are seeing a broader cultural emphasis on building muscle and achieving a particular body ideal, especially among boys and young men," said Ganson. "Social media may be contributing to these pressures by normalizing supplement use as part of everyday fitness routines. However, it is important to recognize that not all supplement use is inherently problematic, and the reasons young people use these products can vary considerably." 

The researchers emphasize that while protein and creatine supplements are legal and widely available, their use should not automatically be assumed to be risk-free. Although these products may offer benefits when used appropriately, potential concerns include excessive dosing, combining multiple supplements, product quality, and use driven by body dissatisfaction or unrealistic expectations about physical appearance. 

The findings point to opportunities for college and university health services, athletic programs, and other health professionals to provide evidence-based education and support. 

"While many health professionals are not well-trained on APEDS, they should be asking young people about their use of muscle-building supplements in the same way they routinely assess other health behaviors," said Ganson. "We have outlined how to engage in these conversations, which should be nonjudgmental and focus on understanding motivations for use, identifying potentially harmful practices, and providing accurate information about safety and effectiveness." 

The researchers also highlight the importance of targeted prevention and education efforts among student-athletes, who reported higher use of protein supplements, creatine supplements, and anabolic-androgenic steroids than their non-athlete peers. 

"Universities have an important opportunity to integrate APEDS-related education into existing student health, wellness, and athletic programs," Ganson added. "Rather than relying solely on messages discouraging use, we need practical, evidence-based approaches that help young people make informed decisions about their health." 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Effectiveness and Implementation of a Teacher Leader Program

 

The Institute of Education Sciences has released a new evaluation report, Study of a Teacher Leader Program: Effects on Student Achievement and Teacher Retention, that assesses the effectiveness of a teacher leader program in increasing student achievement and teacher retention and examines how its implementation may have influenced its effectiveness.

The study randomly assigned 87 elementary schools in five states to either implement the program or continue with their usual strategies for supporting teachers and compared outcomes between the two groups of schools after two years. The study took place between 2020 and 2023, a period that coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic and its aftermath; therefore, the findings reflect the effects of the program as it was implemented during this unique context.

Improving student achievement and teacher retention have been pressing priorities for federal education policy, particularly in schools that serve a large share of students in poverty. To address these priorities, Congress established the Teacher and School Leader (TSL) incentive grant program, which has awarded more than $1 billion since 2016. A common strategy used by recent TSL grantees has been to establish teacher leader programs, in which schools designate high-performing teacher leaders to provide personalized coaching to their peers while continuing to teach their own classes. To inform the TSL grant program and expand the evidence base on teacher leader programs, this study assessed the effectiveness of a teacher leader program with common features of TSL-funded programs.

Key findings include:

  • Many schools did not hire or maintain the expected number of teacher leaders, and few provided the expected amount of principal support or release time from classroom instruction.
  • Teacher leaders did not provide the expected amount of personalized coaching to their peers, but the program still increased the amount of personalized coaching teachers received.
  • The teacher leader program did not achieve its primary goals of increasing student achievement and teacher retention. Exploratory analysis showed, however, that when teacher leaders provided higher amounts of coaching, the program had positive effects on achievement.
  • Despite not being implemented as intended, the program improved some aspects of teacher collaboration, the use of key instructional practices, and job satisfaction.

To access the report, please visit https://ies.ed.gov/use-work/evaluations.

Teens who report greater parental involvement are more likely to help cyberbullying victims

A new study finds that teens who perceive greater parental involvement and communication about their online lives report more empathy for cyberbullying victims and a greater willingness to help them. This involvement was only weakly related, or unrelated, to time spent online and exposure to harmful content. The findings come from testing a new questionnaire with 617 adolescents, examining their online experiences, reactions to cyberbullying and communication with parents.

 For parents worried about their teenagers’ online lives, “How much screen time?” may not be the most important question.

A new study by Prof. Ariel Knafo-Noam and Sharon Cayzer-Haller of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and Dr. Hila Segal of the Academic College of Tel Aviv-Yaffo, has developed a new tool designed to provide a fuller picture of what adolescents actually experience online. The study was published in the International Journal of Bullying Prevention.

The researchers developed the Online Behavior Questionnaire (OBQ), a 43-item questionnaire that examines six interconnected aspects of teenagers’ digital lives. These include how much and how they use the internet, their exposure to harmful content, how they feel when witnessing cyberbullying, how they say they would respond, and how they perceive communication and involvement from their parents.

Rather than treating screen time, cyberbullying and parenting as separate issues, the questionnaire is designed to examine how these different parts of a teenager’s online world fit together.

The tool was tested using two independent samples involving a total of 617 adolescents. Participants were presented with realistic cyberbullying situations, including scenarios involving ridicule over appearance, academic performance and body image, and were asked both how the situations made them feel and how they would respond. The questionnaire showed a largely consistent structure across the two groups, supporting its potential as a research tool for understanding adolescents’ digital experiences.

One of the study’s notable findings was that teenagers who perceived greater parental involvement and communication around their online lives also tended to report more sympathetic emotional reactions and more supportive responses when witnessing cyberbullying. At the same time, perceived parental involvement was only weakly related, or unrelated, to how much time adolescents spent online or how much harmful content they encountered.

In other words, parental involvement may be linked less to keeping teenagers away from the internet and more to how they respond when something harmful happens there. Because the study was based on self-reports and measured participants at one point in time, however, it cannot establish that parental involvement directly causes more empathetic behavior.

“Teenagers’ digital lives cannot be understood simply by counting the hours they spend in front of a screen,” the researchers said. “What they encounter online, how they respond when they see someone being harmed, and whether they feel able to communicate with their parents are all part of the picture. By looking at these experiences together, we can begin to better understand where young people may need support and how families and educators can help.”

The findings also suggest that adolescents’ digital experiences can be broadly divided into two areas. One involves their general online activity and exposure to harmful content. The other involves how they emotionally and behaviorally react when witnessing online aggression, together with their perceptions of parental communication and involvement. This distinction suggests that efforts to encourage teenagers to become more empathetic or active bystanders online do not necessarily have to focus on reducing their overall internet use.

The researchers say the OBQ could eventually help educators and researchers identify different patterns of online risk and protection. For example, some teenagers may recognize that cyberbullying is wrong but hesitate to intervene, while others may dismiss or reinforce harmful behavior. Understanding these differences could help shape more targeted programs that teach young people how to respond, report abuse and support victims.

For now, the researchers caution that the questionnaire is primarily a research and preliminary assessment tool. Further studies across different cultures and populations, as well as longitudinal research, will be needed before it can be widely used for screening or evaluating interventions.

School environment plays key role in shaping parents' educational hopes for their children


Parental expectations are one of the strongest predictors of how far a child will go in their education

Where segregation is high, the school a child attends is closely linked to how many years of education parents expect their child to go on to complete.

That's the suggestion of a new study, published in the peer-reviewed journal Educational Psychology, which analysed more than 180,000 students' transition from primary to secondary school.

The findings of the paper – carried out by academics from the Université Lumière Lyon 2, in France, the Haute École Pédagogique Vaud, in Switzerland, and the Universidad de O'Higgins, in Chile – suggest that schools could play a more active role in supporting and encouraging parents' expectations for their children's futures, particularly in communities with fewer economic resources.

Lead author Ludivine Jamain, from the Institut de Psychologie at Université Lumière Lyon 2, says the outcomes of their study link to an important part of children’s futures.

"Parental expectations are not just a private family matter; they are one of the strongest predictors we have of how far a child will go in their education," she states.

" What our study suggests is that these expectations are associated not only with family characteristics but also with the school a child attends. Even when two families have similar income and education levels, if one child attends a lower-income school and the other attends a higher-income school, their parents end up with noticeably different expectations for their futures.

"This matters because higher parental expectations are consistently linked to better academic outcomes, so a child's school is not just shaping their learning environment; it may also be shaping how far their own parents believe they can go."

To carry out their analysis, the team examined how a combination of family circumstances, student characteristics, and school environments related to how many years of education parents expected their children to complete.

The team's longitudinal data set included 183,060 Chilean students as they moved from primary school (8th grade) to secondary school (10th grade). This covered 5,931 primary schools and 2,910 secondary schools.

The study found that, of all the various aspects of a school the researchers examined – including how rural it was, its average test scores, and how parents rated it – the wealth of the families attending the school stood out as having the strongest link to parental expectations.

Children attending lower-income schools were linked to parents expecting roughly six-tenths of a year less education for their child, compared with children at the highest-income schools.

This held true even after accounting for the family's own income, parental education, the child's academic performance, and prior parental expectations, suggesting that the socioeconomic composition of the school is associated with parental expectations beyond individual family characteristics.

Separately from this school effect, the researchers also found that a family's own income made a difference: parents with higher household incomes expected more years of education for their children.

The researchers also found that the connection between a parent's own level of education and their expectations for their child was stronger in lower-income schools than in medium-income schools.

"In practical terms, this means that two parents with the same level of education could end up expecting quite different outcomes for their children, depending on which type of school their child attends, with the gap between more and less educated parents widening in lower-income school settings," explains co-author Marine Hascoët, from the Haute École Pédagogique Vaud in Switzerland

Beyond school income level, several family and student factors were also linked to higher parental expectations. These include:

  • Families with more than 100 books at home have noticeably higher expectations than families with none
  • Gender: parents expected slightly more years of education for daughters than for sons
  • Children who performed well in mathematics were consistently linked to higher parental expectations, more so than performance in reading

The findings point to various practical steps that schools could take.

"Rather than focusing only on individual families, schools serving lower-income communities could benefit from structured communication strategies that clearly explain academic pathways and post-secondary opportunities to parents,” explains co-author Valentina Sofia Giaconi Smoje, an Associate Professor at the University of O'Higgins.

"Such efforts would not be about changing parents' attitudes directly, but about improving the information and school environments that shape those attitudes in the first place."

As with all studies of this nature, there were several limitations. The survey did not capture every possible belief or aspiration parents might hold for their children

Also, because the study is observational, it cannot establish whether school environments cause changes in how many years of education parents expect their children to complete, or whether the relationship may operate in both directions.
The study's authors propose this two-way relationship between schools and families as a key direction for future research.

Monday, November 16, 2026

A Survey of Undergraduates on Impacts of AI in Higher Education

This study reports findings from the first wave of a survey of undergraduates including separate samples of Dartmouth students, graduating high school seniors, and U.S. college students more broadly. 

Students report extensive use of AI both for tasks which are likely harmful to learning and tasks which are likely helpful to learning. Students report much higher peer misuse of AI relative to reports of own misuse. 

Ninety-two percent of students agree or strongly agree that use of AI is harmful to writing. Use of graded out-of-class assignments has become increasingly unfair due to cheating with AI. But students see the value of using AI to answer conceptual questions in real time, create practice quizzes and study guides and to enable meaningful and efficient progress on research projects. 

Eighty-four percent of Dartmouth respondents report that AI is changing the nature of jobs in their desired (future) field as opposed to eliminating jobs. 

AI’s perceived value and harms vary widely by academic discipline suggesting that use, rules, and approaches must also vary greatly based on the discipline and context. 

Students are largely self-taught in AI but have strong demand for incorporating AI effectively in the curriculum.

Parental Beliefs and Public Policies in Financing Higher Education

 Parents who want to financially support their child’s pursuit of higher education must save against assumptions about what college will cost and how it will be funded. This study examines how parental beliefs and future borrowing costs shape college saving decisions. Through a survey experiment with an embedded financial planning tool, the authors elicit parental beliefs about the future costs of college and their expectations of different funding sources, including financial aid and student loans. 

The authors find that nearly all parents want to cover some of the future costs of college, but many may fall short in their savings due to underestimating future expenses and overestimating available financial aid. A corrective information intervention encourages most parents to recalibrate their saving target. However, when a substantial gap between expected and actual costs is combined with a salient high repayment burden for their child, the authors  find a discouragement effect that diminishes both their willingness to save and their aspirations for their child’s educational attainment. 

The authors calibrate a model of parental saving with learning about college costs, which reproduces both the absence of an average response to borrowing costs and the shift of children away from college attendance, and use it to price the welfare cost of misperception. Parents with higher financial literacy hold better-calibrated beliefs and respond more to correction. 

The authors discuss policy implications for outreach activities to support informed financial planning for college education.